Don’t You Trust Me? New Research on Fear, Trust, and Digital Parenting

“Don’t you trust me?”

When either of my kids asks me this question, it seems to stop time for a moment. The question hangs there between us, equal parts accusation and earnest inquiry. My first impulse is often to start the clock again with a quick and emphatic defense of our relationship: “Of course I trust you!”

Another impulse is to internally tick through evidence of past missteps and potential future pitfalls and then deflect: “This has nothing to do with trust.” Parenting, after all, can be an endless exercise in contemplating all the ways things might go wrong. 

It’s tricky because the question of trust often shows up right when we are negotiating the tenuous balance between limits and freedom. Questions like “Who else is in the group chat you want to join?” or “We agreed that your phone would be across the room while you study. What’s your plan for that while we are gone tonight?” can feel like a genuine affront to our kids’ growing need for autonomy and independence.

The more accurate answer to their question is a little more complicated than a simple yes or no. Trust is not an all-or-nothing proposition. How we translate trust into action depends on all kinds of things, including:

  • Who our kids are, including their unique strengths, skills, and vulnerabilities
  • What is going on around us, including the social context and environment
  • How we are feeling, including how much sleep we have had and the strength of the thread we are hanging on by

Given all of this, a more measured response to an indignant question about trust might be:

“Yes, I trust you. And trust is built over time. And I know that our trust in each other is likely to be ruptured and repaired many times as you grow up. And my job is to verify trust with purposeful guardrails. And I am confident that we will figure it out together.”

Kids don’t benefit from this kind of long-winded monologue. These are conversations we return to over time. But we also shouldn’t dodge the big-picture importance of the original question. A new study exploring “mindsets” in digital parenting invites us to pause and reflect on how our beliefs about technology, and trust in our kids’ capacities, shape the way we show up for them.

Mindsets for digital parenting

As parents, we are inundated with messages and advice about screen time. We read a lot about technology’s impact on adolescents. But how do those messages impact our parenting mindsets? And how do those mindsets impact our kids? 

A group of researchers recently set out to better understand these questions. First, the team developed two theoretically grounded digital parenting mindsets they called “fear-based” and “trust-based” mindsets. A fear-based mindset focuses on technology as a threat. A trust-based mindset reflects confidence in adolescents’ growing capacity to learn and manage technology with support and experience. Researcher and clinical psychologist Jacqueline Nesi wrote a compelling essay summarizing the study. Though not one of the authors, she shared the kinds of statements that parents might agree with within each mindset. 

On a scale from strongly disagree to strongly agree, parents with a fear-based mindset were more likely to agree with statements like:

  • Screen time is one of the biggest threats to children today
  • Screen time is destroying childhood
  • Screens are dangerous for my child

Parents with a trust-based mindset were more likely to agree with statements like:

  • I trust that my child will learn to balance screen time with other activities
  • I believe my child will ultimately be capable of managing screen time responsibly
  • My child can ultimately learn to manage screen time responsibly from making good and bad decisions now

The benefits of a “trust-based” mindset

The researchers then looked at how these mindsets were related to parenting behaviors and how their kids (ages 10-16) were doing. The research spanned several studies and included parents from four countries. Perhaps unsurprisingly, parents who had a “trust-based” mindset were more likely to be warm and responsive. But the benefits didn’t stop there. Their teens reported more positive uses of technology, better self-regulation, feeling more trusted, having more voice. A “fear-based” mindset was not associated with those same benefits. Instead, these parents were more likely to use control-based strategies and to feel more stressed and less effective. The trust-based mindset had stronger effects overall. 

To sum up their findings, the authors of the study noted, “parents have more to gain with a trust-based mindset than they have to gain, or lose, with a fear-based mindset.”

Trust doesn’t mean unconcerned or hands-off

Importantly, parents with a trust-based mindset were no less likely than parents with a fear-based mindset to monitor their kids’ online activities or use parental controls. In other words, these parents did not take an unconcerned “hands off and hope” approach to digital parenting.

This study can’t tell us if kids’ online behaviors shaped their parents’ mindsets or the other way around (or both directions, or a third variable altogether). You can certainly imagine a scenario where a child really struggling with technology evokes a more controlling and fearful response from their parent.

Even so, it’s worth considering the downsides of control-based strategies and the potential benefits of a mindset shift. Previous research shows that many of the attributes of a “trust-based” mindset are associated with positive outcomes for kids. For example, “autonomy-supportive parenting” is associated with stronger self-regulation, fewer depressive and anxiety symptoms, and higher self-esteem, among other benefits. Like the trust-based mindset, autonomy-supportive parenting isn’t a call to let kids do whatever they want. Adolescent psychologist Dr. Lisa Damour sums up a mountain of research on parenting teens in more simple terms: “There are two things that teens need more than anything else: warmth and structure.” 

In other words, we don’t have to choose between a trust-based mindset and purposeful boundaries. Our kids benefit from both.

Our fears are real, but let’s not put them in charge

All of this sounds wonderful on paper. But when it comes to technology, cultivating a trust-mindset is not easy. We are on the receiving end of a steady stream of fear-based messaging, making it hard not to internalize short-hand beliefs like:

  • Who our kids are = vulnerable 
  • What is going on around us = bad
  • How we are feeling = scared

To be clear, there is plenty to be concerned about when it comes to tech. Our worry and exhaustion are legitimate and sometimes based on real observations of suffering. But when our rage at tech companies and critique of exploitative design seep into every tech-related interaction with kids, everyone loses. When all we can see is red, we miss green flags right in front of us. This can obscure one of the clear takeaways from the research: that bad outcomes are not inevitable. They are shaped by who a kid is, what they are doing online, and what tech is crowding out – not just the presence or absence of a device in their hand.

Room for possibility, room for learning

A trust-mindset does not mean unconcerned. This is where it is helpful to to lean into Dr. Jacqueline Nesi’s reminder that mindsets are not the same thing as feelings. Some amount of fear and worry is part of the gig. But feelings are different from the broader “interpretive framework” we use to help us make sense of our kids’ behaviors and figure out what to do next. That’s where mindset comes in.

Here’s how it can shape interactions. If my kid shares that he had a misunderstanding with a friend on a text thread, a fear-based mindset might interpret this as confirmation that tech is a toxic force and that things are only going to get worse. Amped up with parental anxiety, my reaction might be to launch into a lecture about cyberbullying or take his phone – no questions asked. 

A mindset powered by trust might help me slow down and take in a more accurate and whole picture before choosing the next move. This second scenario isn’t a free pass to jump into every 50 kid group chat in school. But it does open up different opportunities. 

There’s room to evaluate the context: How’s the group chat been going overall? There’s room for voice and perspective: How does my child experience what is happening? What are they hoping for from telling us? There’s room for the possibility that a similar conflict might have played out on the soccer field or in the hallway. And even if I need to enforce a boundary, there’s room to consider how to couple that with social skill building that will serve them online and offline.

This study is one more reminder that a trust-based mindset may promote “safer engagement in the digital age.” It may better protect adolescents from the very risks that we are most scared of.

“We are on the same team”

Our kids’ brains are transforming at the same time that their digital worlds are expanding. Trending topics, headlines, clips, and snippets continuously remind us of all the ways things can go wrong. 

But the latest science of adolescence is not just a story of vulnerability and risk. The adolescent brain is built for connection, learning, purpose, and discovery. Their experiences with technology are deeply mixed, if only we pause long enough to see them. Our belief in the long arc of healthy development helps build trust in who they are becoming. This belief matters most when the road gets bumpy, which it will.

Communicating to our teens that we are on the same team matters. This doesn’t mean being best online friends or blanket access to the internet. It also doesn’t mean taking over completely through control and restriction. It means that when they ask us, “Don’t you trust me?” we can answer honestly and in its full complexity. “Yes. And we keep building trust over time with both boundaries and freedom. We will figure this out together.”